View from the street: HS2 is a waste of money needed for education and NHS

PUBLISHED: 12:00 04 February 2018


Back in 2010, they said it was about connecting Glasgow, Scotland to England, then they said it was about saving 11 minutes on the journey from London to Birmingham (really? that was worth £56billion?), then it was about capacity, but they would only have to add more carriages and make the platforms longer, so then it was an “engine for growth” regenerating the north and creating jobs.

But to stimulate the economy and create jobs they would only need to upgrade and electrify the existing tracks, build the trans-pennine, install in-cabin signalling for efficient timetabling as well as safety. You don’t need to build another railway to London through an area of natural beauty like the Chilterns, destroying ancient woodlands.

Why waste over £100billion (Michael Byng) on HS2 when we need the money for the NHS and the education system? The House of Lords Economic committee declared the business case not made, but were ignored.

The truth is we wouldn’t even get a high speed railway the nation could be proud of – it is old technology and will be entirely out of date before it is finished in 2033.

And while they are constructing it air pollution and traffic congestion around Euston and Camden will get even worse with an extra 650 heavy goods vehicles on the roads every day.

Without yet having a station design, nor having published a viable scheme for bringing high speed rail into Euston, HS2 Ltd is evicting people using compulsory purchase orders without paying any compensation at the time of eviction just two weeks before Christmas, and felling the trees around Euston, St James Gardens laid waste by New Year.

They seem keen to demolish the whole area around Euston where 17,000 people live, ready for the developers to make a profit – it is not brownfield ripe for regeneration like around Kings Cross.

The community has been badly let down by democratic processes such as petitioning the select committees, responding to consultations, supposedly experiencing “engagement” from HS2 which is after all the Department of Transport, our government.

Our taxes are used to pay spin firms to portray us as rich nimbies denying the north their jobs – whereas our communities live on the estates around the mainline railway stations that have become desirable real estate, suffering austerity and inequality while developers build high rise office blocks, shopping malls and luxury flats for foreign investment.

So why are they going ahead with HS2 despite the cost, disadvantages and lost opportunities outweighing any national benefit, undeterred by the failure of neo-liberal economy or the exposure of dishonest rationales?

In this post democratic system with democracy hollowed out, it is the vested interest who steer our politicians, driven by the billion pound lobbying machine. Through revolving doors the politicians become company directors, while the corporations take the roles of civil servants, and we citizens have no voice.

Sign the petition to cancel HS2:

Latest Hampstead & Highgate Stories

37 minutes ago

New Arsenal head coach Unai Emery has been in bullish form on his first day in the job after chief executive Ivan Gazidis unveiled the 46-year-old Spaniard on Wednesday – insisting the North London giants can catch Manchester City next season.

North London and South Hampstead will do battle this weekend in Division Three while Division Two outfit Hornsey visit Wycombe House


Spaniard has been chosen to replace legendary Frenchman at the helm of the Premier League club

The N8 club failed to defend a total of 332 against their local rivals last weekend, but will aim to bounce back on Saturday against Finchley

The 24-year-old Londoner discussed the importance of believing and highlighted the success of other not fancied teams in the past


Batsman opened against Essex, but came in at number three against Kent

The Shepherd’s Cot club chased down 333 against their local rivals at the weekend to win for the first time since promotion to the top flight


Football’s worst kept secret is out – Arsenal have officially confirmed Unai Emery will become the club’s new head coach.


Wembley Sailing Club is hosting a Push the Boat Out event on Sunday May 20, where those interested in taking up the sport are invited to experience the club in action.

Preparing your child in advance for school will go a long way towards ensuring the very best start for your child.

After over 50 years in the acting industry, and a decade of unprecedented success delivering outstanding part-time performing arts tuition at her weekend Academies across the country, Pauline Quirke returns to her roots to create even more opportunities for young performers in North London.

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to the following newsletters:

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Most read Hampstead & Highgate stories

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition


Enjoy the
Hampstead & Highgate Express
e-edition today


Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now