Search

Spurs boss Sherwood has given ammunition to his critics after Arsenal defeat

11:59 06 January 2014

Tim Sherwood on the touchline at the Emirates

Tim Sherwood on the touchline at the Emirates

EMPICS Sport

Spurs correspondent Ben Pearce looks back on Tottenham’s defeat in Saturday’s north London derby at Arsenal and discusses Tim Sherwood’s tactics.

Tim Sherwood is not the first Tottenham manager to face the tactical problem of how to take on Arsenal at the Emirates.

Arsenal are well-versed in the 4-3-3 system, and they do it better than Spurs. So do you match the Gunners’ formation and play them at their own game, in their own stadium, or do you pose them a different problem and play 4-4-2 (or 4-4-1-1)?

A brief history lesson is possibly required to underline the positives and pitfalls in each approach.

In October 2009 Harry Redknapp opted for a 4-3-3 formation with Wilson Palacios, Jermaine Jenas and Tom Huddlestone in the centre, leaving Peter Crouch isolated up front – and a toothless Tottenham side lost 3-0.

In November 2010 Redknapp went for 4-4-1-1, with Rafael van der Vaart behind Roman Pavlyuchenko and found his side 2-0 down after 27 minutes.

The manager said his side were “very open” and got “overrun in the middle of the park” – yet it was an attacking “gamble” that sparked the comeback.

Jermain Defoe replaced Aaron Lennon at half-time, joining Roman Pavlyuchenko in a 4-4-2 formation, and the Lilywhites famously fought back to win 3-2.

The following season Redknapp started with Emmanuel Adebayor and Louis Saha up front, and after 34 minutes both strikers had scored and Spurs were 2-0 up. Then Arsenal took control and, in the 68th minute, the Gunners were winning 5-2.

Andre Villas-Boas used a 4-4-2 formation for the first time at the Emirates last campaign. Once again, Spurs started brilliantly, with Defoe creating Adebayor’s opening goal in the 10th minute.

However, the Togo international was then sent off eight minutes later, at a time when Tottenham were well on top, and they were beaten 5-2 again.

At the start of this season, Villas-Boas opted for a more cautious 4-3-3 system, with Etienne Capoue, Paulinho and Mousa Dembele in the middle. But, rather like in 2009, that left the lone striker, Roberto Soldado, isolated and Spurs lost 1-0.

Ultimately, an aggressive approach has had mixed results – goals at both ends – while Tottenham have failed to score on both of the occasions when they set out trying to emulate Arsene Wenger’s side.

Given that Sherwood has played a 4-4-2 system – with one striker dropping deep – away at both Southampton and Manchester United, it always looked likely that he would favour the more ambitious, offensive approach – and he lost.

It was arguably overly brave to hand 19-year-old Nabil Bentaleb his first start in the two-man central midfield rather than opting for the more defensive Etienne Capoue, but there are many mitigating factors in the defeat.

Having taken over on December 16, Sherwood has overseen six games in 18 days amidst a crippling injury list.

No less than 10 players were unavailable at the weekend, and there were precious few options on a severely weakened bench to help him change the game, while Wenger was able to introduce Per Mertesacker, Mathieu Flamini and Mesut Ozil.

Adebayor had been taken off the Old Trafford pitch three days earlier on the stretcher, due to cramp, but he started again at the Emirates - as did nine of his team-mates. While it was hoped that the rejuvenated forward would be Spurs’ talisman against his former club, it was probably unrealistic.

Meanwhile, unlike in previous seasons, Arsenal are currently the league leaders, and they had home advantage. There was arguably no tougher game for this weary Spurs side to face at the end of their gruelling festive period.

It is easy, with the luxury of hindsight, to say Sherwood was naïve and that he should have played an extra man in midfield.

However, Spurs lost at Arsenal earlier this season when they tried to negate the Gunners’ threat rather than imposing themselves on the hosts – and Sherwood’s whole ideology is to turn that dichotomy on its head.

If he had withdrawn a striker, packed the midfield and been defeated, he would probably have been accused of showing fear against Spurs’ bitter north London rivals, taking a backward step and bottling it in the game that the fans care about most.

Had he simply stated “we gambled and lost” on Saturday evening, few could have criticised him – particularly given his recent successes with the very same approach.

However, the tactical mismatch in midfield was there for all to see, and Sherwood’s comments in his post-match press conference did him few favours.

“I don’t think we were overrun in the middle of the park, I think they [the players] did alright,” he said. “A lot is made of systems - 4-4-2, 4-3-3 or whatever you want to call it.

“It’s about passing the ball to your own team and keeping hold of it because when you lose the ball you are always going to be out of shape - otherwise you are going to be a rigid, boring team.”

By ignoring the relevance of the two formations, Sherwood has given ammunition to the critics who question his tactical nous – and his dismissal of the difference between a 4-4-2 and a 4-3-3 system was particularly ill-advised.

It seemed, after 60 minutes of the match, that the head coach had seen enough and was ready to make a change – Nacer Chadli was just about to replace Soldado when Arsenal scored their second goal.

However, Sherwood stated after the game that the change was an enforced one because Soldado was injured, not because he had decided to switch to a Plan B. The result is that it is still unclear whether Sherwood knows when to alter his approach, either from the start or during a match.

He will have anticipated such a reaction to the derby defeat. Indeed, the last thing he said in Friday’s pre-match press conference was: “It’s a new era, we’re looking forward and hopefully we can continue with the results - but that’s what it’s all about.

“Suddenly it could be all doom and gloom [if we lose]. [People will say] I’m the worst manager, the most inexperienced manager, and then everything is rubbish. That’s what happens. I’m realistic, I know how it all works.”

With that in mind, Sherwood may wish he could reconsider his post-match analysis, because that was the most concerning aspect of Saturday’s defeat - not his ambition.

Follow me on Twitter @BenPearceSpurs

0 comments

Latest Hampstead & Highgate Sports News

Yesterday, 22:41
Essex's Ashar Zaidi

Pakistan all-rounder Ashar Zaidi blazed an unbeaten half-century to strengthen Essex’s chances of joining Middlesex in the NatWest T20 Blast quarter-finals.

Yesterday, 09:14
Sean Cronin leaps to win a header during Monday's victory over Maidenhead. Pic: Martin Addison

Sean Cronin is hoping his experience at the back can enable Wingate & Finchley to challenge for the Ryman League Premier Division play-offs this season.

Yesterday, 07:06
Nathan Sowter has become a regular member of Middlesex's T20 side. Pic: Gavin Ellis/TGS Photo

Leg-spinner Nathan Sowter is seeking to play his part in a rare Twenty20 double for Middlesex this season.

Tue, 18:52
Spurs Ladies forward Bianca Baptiste (right). Pic: Clive Jones

Spurs Ladies won a cup double last season and forward Bianca Baptiste would love to go one better and secure a treble this term – but she believes the focus should be on the league and a top-three finish.

Tue, 18:35
Lyon's Alexandre Lacazette

Lyon have refuted reports that they have received a second bid from Arsenal for star striker Alexandre Lacazette.

Tue, 15:14
Tottenham manager Mauricio Pochettino

Mauricio Pochettino has shown his willingness to put his faith in Tottenham’s youngsters on plenty of occasions, and they will usually thank him for it.

Tue, 07:30
North London players celebrate a wicket from Jordan Gregory in their five-run win against Brentham. Pic: Max Flego

Captain Sam Bardon has urged North London to maintain the impetus of their seven-match unbeaten run as they prepare to face the top two sides in Middlesex County League Division Three.

Mon, 17:06
Joel Hughes has taken 100 wickets for North Middlesex in the Premier Division. Pic: Paolo Minoli

North Middlesex secured their fourth straight Premier Division victory after beating second-placed Teddington by two runs – and captain Tom Nicoll believes the strength of his side’s bowling attack means they have a shot at the title.

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to the following newsletters:

Most read Hampstead & Highgate sport

HOT JOBS

Show Job Lists

Property Newsletter Sign-up

Get the latest North London property news and features straight to your inbox with our regular newsletter

I am also happy to receive other emails...
Fields marked with a * are mandatory
Email Marketing by e-shot

Competitions

Which book character do you share cleaning habits with?

Whether you have more in common with put-upon Cinderella, emotionally turbulent Jane Eyre, or easily distracted Mole, you’re sure to appreciate that one lucky winner will receive four sessions of free cleaning. Enter our quiz for your chance to win. All runners up will get £10 off their first clean when making a repeat booking.

£15k prize bundle

Imagine having the opportunity to win an incredible £15,000 bundle of some of the most amazing prizes available. Well, for one lucky contest entrant that dream could soon become a reality because we at MyOffers are offering an incredible free prize bundle that will make even the most hardened person wild with excitement.

Digital Edition

cover

Enjoy the
Hampstead & Highgate Express
e-edition today

Subscribe

Education and Training

cover

Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now