I’ve discovered that the seller didn’t disclose a defect with my house. Is there anything I can do?

PUBLISHED: 12:06 23 January 2017 | UPDATED: 14:00 23 January 2017

If you've discovered an undisclosed problem with a house you've bought, there are a few solutions

If you've discovered an undisclosed problem with a house you've bought, there are a few solutions


From undisclosed water damage or a mouse infestation to disputes with neighbours, if a seller has not disclosed an issue with a property the buyer may be able to sue or rescind the contract.

Property solicitor Sam Smith of Streathers, Crouch End Property solicitor Sam Smith of Streathers, Crouch End

In a previous article I discussed the steps a buyer can take to try and ensure a seller discloses all relevant information during the course of a property transaction. Unfortunately there will be occasions where a defect is discovered after exchange of contracts or completion that the seller knew about (or arguably should have known about) but did not disclose.

In those circumstances, the remedies available to a buyer will depend on when the defect is discovered and the nature of the seller’s non-disclosure.

If the defect is discovered between exchange and completion, the buyer may: refuse to complete; secure a reduction of the purchase price; or be entitled to damages.

If the defect is only discovered after completion, the buyer may be entitled to rescind the contract and/or claim damages in respect of breach of contract and/or misrepresentation.

It is more likely that the defect will be discovered following completion so I will focus on those remedies here.

The standard conditions of sale, which are incorporated in almost all contracts for the sale of property provide that a buyer can claim damages where there is a material difference between the description or value of the property, or any of the contents included in the contract, as they are represented and as they actually are.

The statement has to amount to one of the following: a description of the property, for example, that it had never suffered from subsidence, when in fact it had; or a statement as to its value, for example the sale price of a comparable house, which turned out to be false.

The standard conditions of sale also provide that a buyer can rescind the contract if either of the following applies: the seller’s error or omission results from fraud or recklessness; or the buyer would be obliged, to its prejudice, to accept property that is substantially different (in quantity, quality or tenure) from that which the buyer had been led to expect by the error or omission. In this scenario, ‘quality’ means the quality of the title being sold or the physical condition of the property.

A claim for misrepresentation is different from a claim for breach of contract. A court has the power to award damages and/or rescission of the contract if a buyer is induced to enter into the contract by a misrepresentation made by the seller and as a result has suffered loss.

There are three types of misrepresentation: fraudulent, negligent and innocent.

An example of a fraudulent misrepresentation is where a seller indicates on the Seller’s Property Information Form that there are no disputes when they know that this is not the case. The buyer relies on these representations for information about the property they are buying and may well not have bought it if they had known the true position.

A negligent misrepresentation would occur where a seller makes a statement to a buyer carelessly or without reasonable grounds for believing its truth.

There is no requirement for the buyer to establish fraud to make a successful claim, only that the statement was in fact false and the burden of proof would rest with the seller to establish that they reasonably believed the truth of the statement.

If the seller can establish this then it becomes an innocent misrepresentation. An innocent misrepresentation can become negligent however where a seller fails to update a buyer when further information comes to light.

The remedies available to a buyer for fraudulent and negligent misrepresentation are rescission and damages. For innocent misrepresentation a court has the discretion to award damages or rescission, but not both.

It is worth noting that the right to rescind a contract may be lost where there is undue delay in bringing a claim. Where the misrepresentation is negligent or innocent time runs from completion. With fraudulent misrepresentation time runs from discovery of the truth.

In some circumstances clauses may be included in the contract to try and minimise or exclude the seller’s liability for misrepresentation. Your solicitor should advise on this prior to exchange of contracts.

This a complex area and should a buyer discover a defect they should notify their solicitor as soon as possible who will provide guidance on the best steps forward.

Sam Smith is a property solicitor at Streathers in Crouch End. Do you have a question for Sam? Email it to ham&high.property@archant.co.uk or tweet @hamhighproperty

Related articles

Property search

e.g. Oxford or NW3
Powered by Zoopla

Other Hampstead and Highgate property news

Home of the week: Room for all your earthly possesions in sought-after Hampstead enclave

An accommodating and beautifully presented, five-bedroom family house, set in the desirable South Hill Park Conservation Area.

Gardens: How best to stock your pond with fish

From picking suitable species to ensuring your pond is safe, Hannah Stephenson runs through some key points to consider before you start.

Hampstead Village to be home to first new build residential block in 20 years

Linton Group have announced Novel House in New End, with seventeen luxury apartments

West Hampstead area guide: shopping, restaurants, schools and transport links

Your guide to all the things to do in West Hampstead, including the best restaurants, shops, bars, cinemas and schools. Plus our guide to property in NW6

3 top properties you can buy or rent in West Hampstead

Here are three properties available to rent or buy in West Hampstead

Want to create a breeding ground for butterflies? You’ll need nettles and long grass

As the charity Butterfly Conservation celebrates its 50th anniversary, its garden expert Natalie Ngo explains how to help the beautiful insects thrive.

Benham & Reeves bought by fellow estate agent chain Dexters

North west London estate agent Benham & Reeves has been taken over by fellow estate agent chain Dexters.

Listed Property Awareness Week: Living in a house with legacy

With more than 5,600 listed buildings in the borough of Camden, many of which are homes, it’s important to know the challenges you face as an owner and how to deal with them. Listed Property Owners’ Club can help

Primrose Hill area guide: Enjoy shopping and eating out in an upmarket village atmosphere

Your guide to all the things to do in Primrose Hill, including the best restaurants, shops, bars, schools and things to do. Plus our guide to property in the area

Three top properties for sale/rent in Primrose Hill

All properties on the market with Goldschmidt & Howland; 020 7043 4433; g-h.co.uk

How to make a bird’s home a happy one

Planning to do your bit for National Nest Box Week? Experts

offer 9 tips to make sure you get the best nest boxes.

Looking for help to get on the ladder? Head to the First Time Buyer Home Show in Stratford for advice on schemes, developments and mortgages

Help is at hand for first-time buyers looking to buy their first home in London

The mortgage time bomb: What interest-only borrowers need to know

Did you know that some home owners could be at risk of losing their property for good - because they’ve ignored correspondence from their lender about how they plan to eventually clear their mortgage debt?

Home of the Week: Apartment in Phillipe Starck designed development

A stunning duplex apartment in The Yoo Building in St. John’s Wood.

How to revamp your bathroom by re-grouting tired tiles

Fancy tackling the job yourself? Follow Chloe Kent’s step-by-step guide.

Gardening: 5 ways to suceed with conifers

Conifers may have a reputation for being boring, but they add valuable colour and structure in winter. An expert offers five growing tips.

Home of the Week: Iconic house in Primrose Hill

This iconic Primrose Hill home, formerly known as The Rocking Horse House, has been beautifully remodelled.

Three great properties to buy in Dartmouth Park

Properties such as semi-detached and terraced Victorian houses with large gardens characterise Dartmouth Park’s streets

Dartmouth Park area guide: pubs, schools and family homes

Your guide to all the things to do in Dartmouth Park, including the best restaurants, pubs, schools and cultural activities in this corner of NW5. PLUS our guide to property in the area

Three great properties to buy in Hornsey

If you’re looking to move into or around the area, here are some ideas

Hornsey area guide: pubs, schools and family homes

Your guide to all the things to do in Hornsey, including the best restaurants, shops, pubs, schools and local history. PLUS our guide to property in the area.

Home of the Week: New build in Hampstead with panoramic views

Newly built property in Hampstead boasts 42ft entertaining room and its own roof terrace

5 issues landlords should consider in 2018

2017 saw a number of changes made to regulations governing the private rented sector and a record number of government consultations held in relation to letting in the UK, meaning there is plenty for landlords to consider and act upon in the new year.

Three great properties for sale in Little Venice

Grand stucco-fronted houses and large Georgian and Victorian brick constructions line the wide streets of Little Venice, whilst charming mews houses can be found on the cobbled street of Bristol Gardens. For the ultimate canalside location nothing can beat a narrow boat.

Little Venice area guide: Canalside lifestyle, cafés and bars, shopping, property and more

Your guide to all the things to do in Little Venice, including the best restaurants, shops, pubs, schools and things to do by the canal. PLUS our guide to property in the area

New two and three-bedroom homes in Hampstead reflect Arts and Craft architecture of area

Thirty nine new two and three-bedroom homes, influenced by the Arts and Crafts architecture of the area, have been launched in Hampstead.

Comment: How to set the asking price for your property

Simon Gerrard, MD of north London estate agents, Martyn Gerrard, offers advice on pricing your house to achieve the best possible result

What you should know about inheriting property

There’s much to consider when inheriting property, writes Fiona Brandhorst

Most Read

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to the following newsletters:

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

2018 © Archant Community Media Ltd

Terms and conditions | Cookie policy | Jobs at Archant