Logo

Aston Chase demand reform of Stamp Duty to reinvigorate London property market

PUBLISHED: 10:00 08 September 2017

This home in Chalcot Square was on the market with Aston Chase for �6,250,000. The Stamp Duty would rack up to �663,750.

This home in Chalcot Square was on the market with Aston Chase for �6,250,000. The Stamp Duty would rack up to �663,750.

Archant

A report by high-end, inner London estate agent, Aston Chase, has called for urgent reform to Stamp Duty and Council Taxes

Founding director of Aston Chase, Mark Pollack, thinks that the London property market could receive a boost from a reform of its onerous property taxes. Founding director of Aston Chase, Mark Pollack, thinks that the London property market could receive a boost from a reform of its onerous property taxes.

A report by inner London estate agent, Aston Chase, has argued that onerous Stamp Duty charges have stagnated the London market and require urgent reform. Property transactions in inner London have declined by 7 per cent according to the report, with house prices following suit.

However, the government is reliant on property and wealth taxes for 7 per cent of tax revenues, with 2.7 per cent of GDP made up from the charges (the second highest in the world). Thanks to large estates, receipts from Stamp Duty have increased by £1 billion over the last year. In addition, £2 billion has been bagged due to the 3 per cent levy on second homes according to Black Brick.

However, last year intake for individual properties actually fell 3 per cent on 2015, to £9.56 million. Aston Chase blames this on the tax, which adversely impacted transaction rates.

Gloucester Lodge in Gloucester Gate, NW1 had an asking price of £12,950,000, with SDLT netting £1,467,750 Gloucester Lodge in Gloucester Gate, NW1 had an asking price of £12,950,000, with SDLT netting £1,467,750

What is the current law?

Stamp Duty was raised for homes worth over £937,500 in 2014 by George Osborne. The Chancellor increased the tax on a £2 million home by over £50,000, whilst raising tax on a £5 million home by over £160,000. In April 2016, a 3 per cent levy was introduced on second homes.

Buyers pay 12 per cent on the value of properties over £1.5 million homes, just under the average cost of a terraced home in Camden according to Zoopla.com. The average terraced home in the borough at a purchase price of £1,664,878 transacted today would require Stamp Duty of £113,535. A flat costing the average of £720,094 would demand £26,004 in Stamp Duty.

This property on Elm Tree Road with Aston Chase is on the market for �7,950,000. The Stamp Duty will total �867,750 This property on Elm Tree Road with Aston Chase is on the market for �7,950,000. The Stamp Duty will total �867,750

What’s the problem?

Aston Chase argue that penalizing the buyer rather than the vendor or owner is unfair, and disproportionately impacts buyers in London. The USA, and several European countries have systems that charge the owner. This week, Mayor Sadiq Khan has argued for devolution of control over property taxes in his draft Housing Strategy for London.

The agent says that Council Tax in its current guise undercharges those living in larger homes, and overtaxes those in smaller properties, argues the estate agent. Council Tax bands have not been updated since 1991 and as such do no reflect changing property values, nor does it differentiate between homes of varying values in the same area.

Mark Pollack, founding director of Aston Chase says: “Stamp Duty is a property transaction tax which has no sound economic basis. It is simply a charge on moving house, which may reduce a person’s ability to move for work, and encourages people to live in homes that are too large (or small) for them. What is required is an annual or exit tax, rather than an entry tax.”

With the penthouse in The Glass Building, NW1 selling for �3.5 million, the Stamp Duty would total �333,750 With the penthouse in The Glass Building, NW1 selling for �3.5 million, the Stamp Duty would total �333,750

A recent study by Lloyds Bank reported that 24% of buyers cited Stamp Duty as the largest factor preventing them from making their second step on the property ladder, and meant they relied on the Bank of Mum and Dad to help.

What are the alternatives?

The agent argues instead that Stamp Duty should be reduced or abolished, in its place enforcing a capital gains tax on primary residence to be paid by the vendor. Alternatively, Council Tax could be reformed by increasing rates for higher value homes or the creation of additional top and bottom bands.

Mr Pollack continues: “If the government wants to retain Stamp Duty then there is a very strong case for reforming the structure of the tax so that simply applies to the value of a property above a threshold rather than the whole value. This would cut revenues by half, but could be balanced by Council Tax rates being reformed.”

Another idea is to introduce a Housing Consumption Tax introduced in place of Council Tax. A flat 0.5 per cent annual tax on the gross value of the home would raise £20.8 billion per year, double that of Stamp Duty currently, according to The Institute for Public Policy Research. This system would rely on valuing different areas and properties across the country.

Additional ideas include following the lead of other European countries to implement a UK Net Wealth Tax, or tax free holidays taken on the capital gains received upon the sale of a home could be abolished. Whilst flawed, Aston Chase argues that implementing the taxes would be beneficial long-term and reinvigorate the market for movers.

Simon Deen, director and head of new homes at Aston Chase says: “All the alternatives that exist in other countries are imperfect, however the UK system is in need of a major overhaul. For example, under the current Council Tax system a person in a one bedroom flat can pay the same Council Tax as the owner of a large house, the system is clearly flawed and could be reformed so that Council Tax levels more closely reflect property capital values.”

Whilst government revenues would fall by £10 billion per year due to the loss of Stamp Duty, a flat-rate local property tax would exceed those receipts, says Mr Deen.

Aston Chase are not alone in their demands. Buying agent Black Brick said: “We would be delighted if the government was prepared to revisit the hike in Stamp Duty. Without doubt, it has reduced transaction levels and added considerable friction to the process of buying and selling property.”

How likely is it?

Numerous reports into property tax have argued for a revision of the current Stamp Duty laws to place the onus on the owner, including Barker (2004), OECD (2011) and Stephens (2011).

The government is under increasing pressure to reform the tax, with Tory leadership favourite Jacob Rees-Mogg backing scrapping the tax, and one unnamed minister urging the Chancellor to “deal with” the tax.

Cuts to Stamp Duty on more expensive properties are likely to go down like a lead balloon from a political standpoint, with Mr Rees-Mogg himself owning a Grade II* listed home in the countryside. As many will see cuts to Stamp Duty on multi-million pound homes as ridding the wealthy of a punitive charge that equates to mere peanuts, cutting the tax would likely be seen as political suicide, with tax increases far more likely than tax cuts.

“The reality is that a cut in rate levied on more expensive properties is highly unlikely,” conclude Black Brick.

Mr Pollack concludes: “If the current Stamp Duty regime continues we face the dangerous possibility that more and more vendors will decide that rather than moving home they will simply refurbish their existing home and gradually the London property market will stagnate and government property tax revenues will start to decline – defeating not only the government’s revenue objectives but also creating a moribund property market.”

Aston Chase, 020 7724 4724

Property search


e.g. Oxford or NW3
Powered by Zoopla

Other Hampstead and Highgate property news

4 ways to transform your Christmas tree

Looking for some seasonal decor inspiration? Gabrielle Fagan reveals her favourite festive finds

Home of the week: Unique penthouse-style apartment in Hampstead

This weeks choice is a property with double volume ceilings and spectacular views over central London

North London developer says the cut to stamp duty is a “gamechanger” for first-time buyers

Abolishing stamp duty for most first-time buyers will make it easier for them to get on the property ladder, according to a north London real estate developer

Comment: My response to the Chancellor’s budget

Trevor Abrahmsohn, director of north London agents Glentree Estates, believes the governments new housing proposals, as part of the Budget 2017, will go some way into making home ownership “a human right, rather than a privilege”

North London agents say government’s abolishment of stamp duty won’t help first-time buyers in the capital

Housing analysts and north London estate agents are among many who believe abolishing stamp duty for first-time buyers will have little impact on the capital’s housing crisis

Winter patio pots looking lacklustre? Try 3 things to perk them up

Perk up your winter pots to keep them looking fabulous over the festive season

How to install a hidden wall safe

A discreet safe to keep valuables protected isn’t just something for the rich and famous to consider. Richard Burr reveals how to fit one

Christmas gift guide: 14 top picks for gardeners and green-fingered types

From sweet stocking-fillers to wow-factor pressies, these are bound to delight

Comment: My letter to our illusive housing minister

According to Simon Gerrard, managing director of Martyn Gerrard estate agents, the government are failing to deliver a strategic approach in response to the housing crisis

Former Hampstead guesthouse is for sale as a 7 bedroom residential home

Owner, Annemarie van der Meer hopes to sell the property to a buyer looking for a spacious family home

For sale in Highgate: top three

On the market this week are three historic properties with period features, high ceilings and far-reaching views in an eviable location

The Japanese wonder toilet taking the world by storm

TOTO, inventor of the ‘Washlet’, claim the rate of sales for their product in Europe has doubled year on year since launching in 2009

5 things to consider before storing your garden tools away for winter

Give your tools some TLC before you put them away for the winter. Our guide shows you how to look after them - and make them last

Home of the week: Converted Hampstead church

This weeks choice is a former Presbyterian Church, boasting a galleried mezzanine floor with rooftop views

Highgate area guide: schools, shops, pubs and parks

Your guide to things to do in Highgate, including the best shops, cafes, restaurants and schools. PLUS our guide to property in N6

Dress it up: 13 fabulous finds for giving your dressing table a mini or major makeover

With party season approaching, it’s time to take a look in the mirror and reassess your beauty station

5 top home improvements you should do instead of moving

Richard Burr reveals how to gain more space in your house

Four in ten London home sellers are cutting asking prices, the highest figure since 2010

Sellers have cut asking prices by an average of 6.7 per cent over the last month, according to new figures

Is it too late to plant bulbs? Not if you follow our guide

There’s still time to plant tulips and bring vibrant colour to your garden next spring

Three new properties on the market in Paddington

Paddington 2 was recently released in cinemas, but there’s more to this area than the bear with a fondness for marmalade

Belsize Park area guide: restaurants, schools, cinema and celebrities

Your guide to things to do in Belsize Park, including the best shops, cafes, restaurants and schools. PLUS our guide to property in NW3

Internationally renowned fireplace brand opens showroom in north London

The new gallery features high ceilings and an abundance of natural light, the perfect space for showcasing fireside, outdoor living and architectural products

3 wallpaper experts reveal their top style tips for 2018

Gabrielle Fagan speaks to those-in-the-know and reveals their top tips and wallpaper trend predictions for next year

Need more storage? How to build sturdy shelves in your alcoves in 5 simple steps

Richard Burr reveals top tips to help DIYers get the job done

For sale in Belsize Park: top three

On the market this week are two stucco-fronted properties with contemporary living space and a red-brick apartment featuring a private terrace

There’s lots to think about when it comes to buying a new carpet

Property columnist Jane Howdle weighs up practicality vs aesthetic

Home of the week: Hampstead Way

This weeks choice is set on a tree lined road, boasting a large lawned garden and an abundance of natural light

Rising interest rates and what it means for homeowners

The hike in interest rates is likely to send mortgage bills higher for millions of families and further disrupt the property market, according to a north London agent

How to make your supermarket basil last longer

Fed up with spending a fortune on supermarket basil? Follow our guide to making it last longer

Why we’re not all equipped for renovating

Columnist Jane Howdle explains why she’ll never buy a property that needs renovating

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to the following newsletters:

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

2017 © Archant Community Media Ltd

Terms and conditions | Cookie policy | Jobs at Archant