An impossible brief: how one architect solved the puzzle of an extension dilemma

PUBLISHED: 18:23 06 February 2017 | UPDATED: 18:34 06 February 2017

How do you make a West Hampstead garden flat feel like it is not in London?

How do you make a West Hampstead garden flat feel like it is not in London?

Studio McLeod

With a broken heart and a dream for her West Hampstead flat to not be in London, Louise Cole had a brief most architects would baulk at. Luckily, that’s what Duncan McLeod loves most

The internal courtyard allows the garden to be viewed from the master bedroom The internal courtyard allows the garden to be viewed from the master bedroom

When your life falls apart, sometimes the only thing to do is knock everything down and start again.

Usually that would simply be a metaphor for clearing away the debris of the past and starting afresh, but for Louise Cole it took the form of something more literal.

After splitting up with her partner in 2010 Louise bought a ground floor flat in Gondar Gardens, West Hampstead.

It was the 100 ft south facing rear garden that attracted her, rather than the Victorian conversion itself.

A folded roof adds visual interest and lets daylight into the space A folded roof adds visual interest and lets daylight into the space

“The flat was a bit ‘meh’ really,” she says.

Dark and poorly laid out, the property was a world away from Louise’s dream of a light, airy home connected to the outside space.

It was a big ask, and Louise struggled to find an architect up to the challenge until a mutual friend introduced her to architect Duncan McLeod.

“She was really good at being very clear with what she wanted. Very quickly in the process we developed a brief, which was seemingly impossible,” says Duncan.

The overhanging roof allows the doors to stay open whatever the weather The overhanging roof allows the doors to stay open whatever the weather

“We really liked that. We actually love it when clients ask for the seemingly impossible. We think it’s really exciting; it challenges us.”

Challenge accepted, Duncan set about developing what has now become Studio McLeod’s signature form of ‘architectural therapy.’

Much like the process of piecing ones life back together again, the puzzle of re structuring the layout of her home would require a fair amount of soul searching alongside the logistics.

“There can be a tendency to respond too quickly as a designer. We very much go in and try and understand that what they are asking for is really what is going to make the biggest difference in their life.”

The wood burning stove is Louise's favourite part of her new home The wood burning stove is Louise's favourite part of her new home

Duncan encourages clients to re evaluate what they want from their homes from the perspective of the why, rather than the what.

“Instead of giving him a list of functional requirements he made me take a step back,” says Louise.

“He asked: ‘how do you live? What do you love?’

The brief they came up with together was ambitious and twofold.

Natural stone and timber flooring defines the living and dining areas in the main reception room Natural stone and timber flooring defines the living and dining areas in the main reception room

“Instead of going for an easy solution we tried to accommodate some of the more crazy stuff,” says Louise

Firstly, she wanted to be able to lie in bed and have a view of the garden.

“I mostly bought it for the garden so it was really important that whatever I did with it I could see the garden,” she says.

Secondly, and even more challengingly, she didn’t want her north London flat to be in the city.

To solve Lousie's brief the architects flipped the layout of the flat To solve Lousie's brief the architects flipped the layout of the flat

“I wanted to feel like I wasn’t in London. I had a busy job and I wanted to come home and feel like I was in the Cornish countryside so that when I came in and shut the door that was it.”

These two requests required a radical alteration of the property, knocking down the existing extension and completely re ordering the layout.

“It was a really bad extension; it was just plonked on the back. Louise had actually paid for somebody else’s mistake, and we were very conscious of that when we did the building,” says Duncan.

The new layout flipped the flat, putting the living and dining area at the rear of the building, with mono sliding glass doors providing an unobstructed view out into the garden.

The origami style folds in the roof allow for plenty of natural light to filter through, whilst the bay window style arrangement of the glass at the back provides a metre more of living space that transitions seamlessly from the interior to the exterior.

To solve the bedroom view dilemma Duncan added an internal courtyard, providing Louise with an unobstructed line of sight through the space and out into the garden beyond. She even has a switch installed by her bed, so she can turn out the outside lights last thing at night.

“We treat every extension we do as a sculptural element, pushing and nudging and stretching it so it is as large as possible for the client without upsetting the neighbours,” he explains.

Duncan sites the art of minimalist sculptors such as James Turrell, Richard Long, Donald Judd as inspiration, and is at pains to stress that ‘minimalist’ doesn’t translate to ‘a plain white box’.

“People want that sculpture, that flair: people call it the wow factor. Most people want to walk into the place they are living in and have their breath taken away a little,” he says.

The budget was tight, and with so much structural work to accommodate Duncan had to be creative with regards to materials without missing out on the chance to wow.

“We ended up with a simple, crafted aesthetic,” he says.

Stained oak flooring in the main living area alludes to the gentle weathering of the Cornish coast, whilst the ‘Tundra’ stone in the dining area gives a “stormy sky” feel.

“It needs to be stunningly beautiful, that is what we aim for. Not because of vanity but because it has hit the right spiritual or natural light feel and the materials all feel right and personal to their lifestyle and taste.”

Six years later the wow factor is still very much there.

“You feel like you are out of London. You get that little piece of peace and quiet. From the outside you would think it is just another terrace, then you shut the front door and it feels like you have entered Narnia,” she says.

To get there required a leap of faith on both the part of the architect and the client.

“There’s a certain element of trust there. They are certainly trusting you with a lot of money and getting it right. You have to go beyond deciding where to put their kitchen and dining room,” says Duncan.

Louise is full of praise for he architect, and the pair remain friends.

“He delivered it beautifully, he delivered it on budget and he looked after me all the way through. He didn’t just dump me with his artistic vision and bugger of and leave me with the builders. He delivered it all – and I got a walk in wardrobe!”

Responding to a break up by knocking down most of your house and gutting the rest might seem like an extreme one, but for Louise the confidence she gained from the experience was important.

“It was one of those big, life changing projects,” she tells me.

“It was one of those moments in your life where you feel you have screwed everything up and this is the project that is going to put you back together again – and it did. I learnt that I was a lot braver than I thought.”

Plus, in a charming twist of fate it, was during the project she met the man who is now her live-in partner.

“I was supposed to live there on my own, but as soon as I started building the flat this bloke arrived and would not leave,” she jokes. “I think it is the wood burning stove. I don’t blame him! He’s been here for six years now; I can’t get rid of him.”

Studio McLeod

320 Kilburn Lane, W9 3EF


Property search

e.g. Oxford or NW3
Powered by Zoopla

Other Hampstead and Highgate property news

Alexandra Palace area guide: the hills, the house and hunting for a bargain

Your guide to things to do in Alexandra Palace, including the best shops, cafes, restaurants and schools. PLUS our guide to property in N22

Comment: What’s in store for 2018?

Trevor Abrahmsohn, managing director of estate agents, Glentree International, offers his predictions for 2018 on everything from property to the World Cup

Primrose Hill family selling historic home after more than 60 Christmases

Originally constructed by renowned Victorian builder William Willett, the seven bedroom house, in Primrose Hill, is now on the market for £15,000,000

North London extensions shortlisted for top design award

Two north London extensions have been shortlisted as among London’s best and most innovative home improvements.

Three table setting themes to inspire you this Christmas

Gabrielle Fagan reveals how to create a Christmas table that’s a feast for the eyes

How to grow your own garlic

If you’re finding that shop-bought garlic doesn’t have the intense flavour you require, then it’s time to start growing your own, which will give you more choice and more flavour.

London house prices now a record 14.5 times higher than average income, figures show

Average house prices reached £496,000 and average earnings were £34,200 in London this year, yet a north London agent says the comparison is not an accurate representation of the capital’s property market

Decor experts Rockett St George reveal their recipe for stunning style

Jane Rockett Lucy St George share their vision for imaginative, inviting interiors with Gabrielle Fagan

Regent’s Park: a historic royal park home to wandering tourists, exclusive elites and everyday Londoners alike

Tom Ford and Damien Hirst might hide away behind the iconic Stucco frontage of the Nash Terraces, but out in the open Londoners mingle with tourists, geese and budding athletes amongst the green space

1960s pebbledash property in Highgate transformed into ‘3D’ family home

The uniquely designed property with an abundance of space, natural light and top of the range amenities, allows the family to dictate how they want to live

How to make a Christmas candle centrepiece for your table

As thoughts turn to festive decorations, garden centre expert Alex Cawley gives us a crafty Christmas masterclass

The reason everyone should own a water butt and how to build one at home

Richard Burr shares his top tips for a DIY rainwater butt

Have your dahlias gone black? It’s time to put them away for the winter - follow our 5-step guide

If you want to enjoy your dahlias next year, dig them up now and store them for winter. Here’s how to do it

The former Camden Mews home of Madness lead singer, Suggs, is for sale

In his autobiography, the former Madness lead singer cited the famous “Our House” single, inspired by the Camden Mews property, as the band’s most successful song

6 things to think about when choosing the right Christmas tree for your home

As Christmas trees arrive in garden centres, expert David Mitchell offers advice to those who only have a small space for a real tree

For sale in Swiss Cottage: top three

This weeks three properties with spacious accommodation, period stain glass windows and a roof terrace

4 ways to transform your Christmas tree

Looking for some seasonal decor inspiration? Gabrielle Fagan reveals her favourite festive finds

Home of the week: Unique penthouse-style apartment in Hampstead

This weeks choice is a property with double volume ceilings and spectacular views over central London

North London developer says the cut to stamp duty is a “gamechanger” for first-time buyers

Abolishing stamp duty for most first-time buyers will make it easier for them to get on the property ladder, according to a north London real estate developer

Comment: My response to the Chancellor’s budget

Trevor Abrahmsohn, director of north London agents Glentree Estates, believes the governments new housing proposals, as part of the Budget 2017, will go some way into making home ownership “a human right, rather than a privilege”

North London agents say government’s abolishment of stamp duty won’t help first-time buyers in the capital

Housing analysts and north London estate agents are among many who believe abolishing stamp duty for first-time buyers will have little impact on the capital’s housing crisis

Winter patio pots looking lacklustre? Try 3 things to perk them up

Perk up your winter pots to keep them looking fabulous over the festive season

How to install a hidden wall safe

A discreet safe to keep valuables protected isn’t just something for the rich and famous to consider. Richard Burr reveals how to fit one

Christmas gift guide: 14 top picks for gardeners and green-fingered types

From sweet stocking-fillers to wow-factor pressies, these are bound to delight

Comment: My letter to our illusive housing minister

According to Simon Gerrard, managing director of Martyn Gerrard estate agents, the government are failing to deliver a strategic approach in response to the housing crisis

Former Hampstead guesthouse is for sale as a 7 bedroom residential home

Owner, Annemarie van der Meer hopes to sell the property to a buyer looking for a spacious family home

For sale in Highgate: top three

On the market this week are three historic properties with period features, high ceilings and far-reaching views in an eviable location

The Japanese wonder toilet taking the world by storm

TOTO, inventor of the ‘Washlet’, claim the rate of sales for their product in Europe has doubled year on year since launching in 2009

5 things to consider before storing your garden tools away for winter

Give your tools some TLC before you put them away for the winter. Our guide shows you how to look after them - and make them last

Home of the week: Converted Hampstead church

This weeks choice is a former Presbyterian Church, boasting a galleried mezzanine floor with rooftop views

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to the following newsletters:

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

2017 © Archant Community Media Ltd

Terms and conditions | Cookie policy | Jobs at Archant