Maida Vale shopper sues Nectar – for 15p

17:00 28 January 2013

Joan Safran with her Nectar card. Picture: Polly Hancock

Joan Safran with her Nectar card. Picture: Polly Hancock


A Maida Vale resident is taking the definition of the small claims court literally – by suing the Nectar shopping rewards scheme for 15pence.

Retired university lecturer Dr Joan Safran has vowed to stand up for shoppers all over the country who, she says, are cheated out of getting the points they deserve when they shop.

The 75-year-old filed a claim on Friday against Nectar on what she said was an important issue of principle. She decided to take up the fight after shopping in the Finchley Road branch of Sainsbury’s late last year.

She spent a total of £32 and paid for it with £15-worth of points and £17 in cash – but only received new reward points for the £17 she spent. If she had paid in cash, the retired philosopher would have received 15p-worth of Nectar points, for which she is now demanding from Nectar.

Dr Safran, who lives off Elgin Avenue, claims Nectar are cheating shoppers out of points they legitimately earn.

She said: “It’s a miniscule amount of money but I just think, ‘How many millions of shoppers?’ It would add up to so much money.

She added: “It cost me £25 to make this suit, but I did it in the public interest. Nectar’s gain is the people’s loss; the establishment is pulling the wool over our eyes. It is the social conscience I have that always costs me money!”

But Nectar said she would not win the case. A Nectar spokesperson said: “We are aware of this claim. However, as stated in the terms and conditions of Nectar membership, Nectar points cannot be earned on any items which are paid for with Nectar points in Sainsbury’s.”

Dr Safran said the company’s actions were unjust and worth taking to court.

She said: “I told them they were breaching their own contract by making us forfeit points. I think I would have noticed if it been happening previously. In fact, the cashier pointed out to me, ‘You have spent £17 today’. But the rest hadn’t been given to me for free because I earned those points already!”


Latest News Stories

Hornsey Town Hall Appreciation Society members. From left Amanda Carrara, Chris Currer, Mark Afford, Miriam Levin and Dave Winskill.

The fight for community ownership of Hornsey Town Hall continues, even though the council officially invited bids from developers last week.

Expedition 45 Commander SCOTT KELLY took this selfie photograph during a 7-hour and 16-minute spacewalk. This was the first spacewalk for both Kelly and Flight Engineer Kjell Lindgren; the two will venture outside the International Space Station for the second time on next Friday. Kelly becomes the U.S. astronaut who has lived in space the longest during a single U.S. spaceflight, and on Monday, Nov. 2, the crew celebrates the 15th year of a continuous human presence in space aboard the station. (Credit Image: © NASA/ZUMA Wire)

Young gardeners are preparing for a close encounter of the herbaceous kind when they attempt to grow seeds from outer space.

Keir Starmer arrives with his wife Victoria at the election count. Picture: Polly Hancock

It’s been six months since Sir Keir Starmer won the safe Labour seat of Holborn and St Pancras by a huge majority.

Yesterday, 17:00
Volunteers plant a new herbaceous border to mark Waterlow Park's 125th anniversary. Picture: Polly Hancock

Volunteers armed with gardening forks and spades replanted a herbaceous border to mark a Highgate park’s 125th anniversary.

Yesterday, 11:00
Bridget Cherry pictured at Hornsey Tower

Bridget Cherry's book, Ivy-Mantled Tower A History of the Church and Churchyard of St Mary Hornsey has been published by The Hornsey Historical Soc. Picture: Nigel Sutton

In telling the story of a long-vanished parish church, architectural historian Bridget Cherry has delved into the heart of what was once Hornsey village.

Yesterday, 10:00
Paul Young, 18, who won the Personal Journey award and was named Inspirational Young Person of the Year at the Camden Youth Awards. Picture: Dieter Perry

Paul Young struggled to cope after suffering mental health problems, being bullied at school, and having to care for his unwell mother.

Fri, 17:29
Crouch End Festival Chorus at St John's Smith Square. Photo: Emily Soppet

The Crouch End Festival Chorus is taking a deep breath and running a 12-hour sponsored singing marathon this Saturday to raise funds for a major recording project.

Fri, 16:48
Flowers on Parkland Walk

Police are investigating after live ammunition was discovered in Parkland Walk.

Most read news

Property Newsletter Sign-up

Get the latest North London property news and features straight to your inbox with our regular newsletter

I am also happy to receive other emails...
Fields marked with a * are mandatory
Email Marketing by e-shot


MAC Makeup

MAC are renowned for their flawless, fabulous make up that is used worldwide by the stars. You too can have the chance to have the perfect makeup to suit your needs with £1,000 to spend on all the glam goodies you like!


You are never far from an Argos, wherever in the country you may be. They are like a magical cavern where whatever you need they seem to have it out the back behind the counter. So why not put them to the test with this great MyOffers competition to win £1000 to spend in-store.

Digital Edition

Read the Hampstead & Highgate Express e-edition today E-edition
Family Notices 24

Local business directory

Our trusted business finder