CS11: Cyclists warn of injury risk as Swiss Cottage work is delayed

PUBLISHED: 15:19 02 August 2018 | UPDATED: 15:19 02 August 2018

An artist's impression of CS11 at Swiss Cottage. Picture: TfL

An artist's impression of CS11 at Swiss Cottage. Picture: TfL


Cycling campaigners have warned that CS11 could be “kicked into the long grass” and lead to riders getting injured at the Swiss Cottage gyratory.

The High Court on the Strand, London. Picture: Anthony Devlin/PA ArchiveThe High Court on the Strand, London. Picture: Anthony Devlin/PA Archive

Simon Munk from the London Cycling Campaign (LCC) said if the work was delayed in the long-term, incidents could happen such as that at Old Street last week, where a cyclist was hit by a cement mixer and left fighting for her life.

A consultation was done between November 2014 and January 2015 into transforming that roundabout but work isn’t due to start until 2019.

Simon said: “One of the first things I did when I started at LCC was speaking to a man whose leg had been mangled when he was hit by a lorry at Swiss Cottage.

“A woman has been very badly hurt at Old Street, in a scheme that has been delayed and pushed back.

CS-11 protest and cyclists counter demonstration at Swiss Cottage, 
Jessica Learmond-Criqui leads the marchCS-11 protest and cyclists counter demonstration at Swiss Cottage, Jessica Learmond-Criqui leads the march

“There’s a risk of this being kicked into the long grass. We have seen the Swiss Cottage gyratory have an awful safety record. It needs to be sorted.”

Sustrans, the national charity for cyclists and pedestrians, has also criticised Westminster City Council for taking TfL to a judicial review.

Ben Addy, head of collaborative design for Sustrans in London, said the council had made a decision on “unfounded fears rather than clear evidence”.

In a two-and-a-half hour hearing last Thursday, a High Court judge passed the borough’s bid for an injunction and a judicial review into the cycle superhighway.

Schoolchildren in Hampstead wear face masks to protest against pollution. Picture: Jessica Learmond-CriquiSchoolchildren in Hampstead wear face masks to protest against pollution. Picture: Jessica Learmond-Criqui

Mr Justice Holgate heard Westminster City Council believed Transport for London (TfL) hadn’t properly modelled traffic for parts of the route, including through St John’s Wood.

Tristan Jones, acting for the borough, also alleged TfL hadn’t properly shared documents with Westminster City Council.

But this was rebuffed by TfL, which said it had shared the same information for the plans with consultants from the council as it had on the Oxford Street pedestrianisation plans.

The High Court also heard the transport body hadn’t shown why the Swiss Cottage gyratory work and work on the 100 Avenue Road plans needed to take place simultaneously. Mr Jones said: “There has been no explanation why they must be done at the same time.”

Andrew Parkinson, assisting the claimant, raised campaigners’ concerns the gyratory section would increase traffic elsewhere in the route, including in Hampstead. Meanwhile Timothy Straker QC, representing TfL, said the council’s “sudden” withdrawal was “politically motivated”. He alleged that Westminster’s backing of the plans was dropped after May’s local elections.

The Conservative-run authority jettisoned support for the Oxford Street works at around the same time.

Several times during the hearing, Mr Justice Holgate aired his frustrations. He said one authority taking the other to court was “like nothing I’ve seen before”.

“Why is the court being troubled by this?” he said. He urged the two parties to have informal mediation talks, and said they should be working together to agree the scheme.

Simon, who has worked at LCC since 2015, said he believes the council’s actions show it is disconnected from residents.

“The legal bid is really a side show. Westminster City Council are out of step with their own residents on this issue. They are making decision and policy based on the needs and wants of drivers from outside the borough.

“They’re working in a very old fashioned way. Not as many residents now have cars and they are prioritising residents from out of London coming into the area.”

The judicial review will take place on September 6. It is expected to last one day.

The work that was set to start in Swiss Cottage this week has now been delayed indefinitely while the judicial review takes place.

Meanwhile, campaigners on the other side of the debate, who have voiced fears CS11 will push traffic into residential streets, were much more pleased. Jessica Learmond-Criqui told the Ham&High: “We are obviously delighted that the judge expressly acknowledged and recognised the concerns of residents about ran running and traffic displacement into Hampstead and St John’s Wood.

“We were very ably assisted by the brilliant planning barrister Andrew Parkinson and couldn’t have done it without him.”

Despite the setback, Simon believes the scheme will go ahead.

“Research shows that they are beneficial,” he said. “There’s no reason other cycle superhighways would be approved, only for the courts to say ‘well, you can’t do this one’ for CS11.”

Related articles

Latest Hampstead & Highgate News Stories


The killers of Camden model Harry Uzoka have been jailed for a combined total of more than 60 years.


High Court judge Sir Ross Cranston, who last week blocked Transport for London’s (TfL) plans to begin building the CS11 cycle superhighway in Swiss Cottage, has denied TfL permission to appeal his judicial review ruling.


Seven months to the day after a single winter night saw two young men stabbed to death, Camden’s youth safety task force – led by Holborn and St Pancras MP Keir Starmer and Cllr Abdul Hai – last night recommended a series of measures to arrest the alarming upwards trend in youth violence in the borough.

Yesterday, 17:30

Letters, contributions and comments sent in from Ham&High readers this week.

There are more than 3,000 homeless families housed by Haringey Council in temporary accommodation in the borough and more than another 1,000 housed outside the borough according to Trust for London.

Yesterday, 15:23

A woman from Temple Fortune turned have-a-go-hero and chased a pair of criminals – causing them to drop a wad of stolen cash – after an elderly woman was robbed at a nearby cashpoint.

Yesterday, 13:15

Haringey Police are appealing for infomration after a 40 year old woman was sexually assaulted on a Muswell Hill Bus.

Yesterday, 12:53

Two rogue swans rapidly regretted the decision to land on the Hampstead Heath ponds when the resident swan family chased them off the water and left them “a bit battered” on a grass verge.


Looking to get your child interested in a sport? Allianz Park, home to rugby union team Saracens, welcomes people of all ages to join their family of supporters and discover how their core values Honesty, Discipline, Humility and Work Rate underpin everything they do off and on the pitch.

As part of a major refurb, the London Marriott Hotel Maida Vale has renamed its three new-look function rooms to reflect the geography and rich history of the area. The largest, perfect for weddings and large meetings, is named after a Hampstead subterranean river, The Westbourne.

Londoners seeking high quality houses for sale within easy commuting distance of the capital are being advised to look north to St Albans’ prestigious Gabriel Square development.

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to the following newsletters:

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

Most read Hampstead & Highgate news

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition


Enjoy the
Hampstead & Highgate Express
e-edition today


Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now