‘I forgive you’ says Highgate grandmother mugged by crack addict for £20

13:35 25 October 2012

Lynne Elmer-Laird, 91, arrives at Wood Green Crown Court alongside an officer in the case to confront her attacker Eric Banton

Lynne Elmer-Laird, 91, arrives at Wood Green Crown Court alongside an officer in the case to confront her attacker Eric Banton


A courageous 91-year-old grandmother says she will forgive the crack addict who viciously mugged her for £20 after he was jailed for 11 years.

Lynne Elmer-Laird - who was mugged for £20.Lynne Elmer-Laird - who was mugged for £20.

Prolific robber Eric Banton, 49, should have been at a probation meeting when he mugged Lynne Elmer-Laird near her home in Highgate – causing such horrific injuries she had to undergo an emergency operation to remove a blood clot.

A day earlier the father-of-three, who has 39 previous convictions, had been given a suspended sentence for shoplifting and celebrated with a crack cocaine binge.

Determined to move on from the attack, Mrs Elmer-Laird, a member of the Highgate Literary and Scientific Institution, took to the stand at Wood Green Crown Court on Friday (October 19) where she confronted 6ft 2in Banton.

Proud son Charles sat in the public gallery as the mugger wept while a list of the grandmother’s injuries were read to the court.

91-year-old Lynne was robbed while out in Highgate91-year-old Lynne was robbed while out in Highgate

The 91-year-old told the court: “My face was black, blue and yellow. I still have injuries which are taking time to heal. My face was such a mess. I couldn’t face going out to see anybody.

“I do go out now with care but I don’t go very far. I’m getting my confidence back and I’m determined to get on with things.”

The court heard how, on August 14, Banton – while still “high as a kite” – followed Mrs Elmer-Laird, who had popped out to the shops.

The army nurse, who survived the Second World War and served in the South Pacific, was walking along Church Road, Highgate, when she felt Banton pulling at her bag.

Former crack addict and prolific robber Eric Banton has been jailed for 11 years for mugging the 91-year-old grandmotherFormer crack addict and prolific robber Eric Banton has been jailed for 11 years for mugging the 91-year-old grandmother

She tried to pull away but fell to the ground, hitting her head on the pavement.

Mrs Elmer-Laird suffered severe swelling to her face and a fractured hand as well as a blood clot on her brain.

“I was so angry with him for leaving me there,” she said. “I still have the scars on my head. It still hurts but it is healing.”

Keith Stones, defending, said jobless Banton had hit “rock bottom” and passed an apology note to the judge on behalf of his client which Mrs Elmer-Laird graciously thanked him for.

“He has a deep sense of shame, and has now realised, when sober, what he has done,” Mr Stones said.

Despite this the defence solicitor said there was “no mitigation for this ghastly offence”.

Sentencing Banton, Judge James Patrick, branded him a danger to the public.

He said: “When he is intoxicated, he loses, as is self-evident, all touch of decency and propriety.

“What you did to her must have devastated not only her, but also her family and friends.

“Even your defence lawyer says there is no mitigation for this ghastly offence. You have shown you are unable to live in society. It is necessary to protect the public from you.”

Speaking after the case Mrs Elmer-Laird said she was happy with the sentence and told the Ham&High she had to forgive Banton because she is a Christian.

“I just feel very sorry for him,” she said. “He has a wife and three children. I don’t know if he will learn anything from it. I’ve never met anyone like him before.

“I just think it is so sad. He is not getting on with his life. Life is so important and precious. I have a wonderful family and beautiful grandchildren. I just feel sorry for him.

“Even if he is off the streets for at least six years it is better than nothing. I don’t want to know him and I don’t want him to know me.

“Pick yourself up, dust yourself down and start all over again. That is my philosophy in life.”

Asked if she would consider moving away from Highgate, she said: “No. Highgate is my home. Charles is in the next road. I am looking forward to being 100. I’m staying put.”

Banton, of Northumberland, Park, Tottenham, pleaded guilty to one count of robbery and must serve at least half his sentence behind bars.

Latest News Stories

Yesterday, 17:56
Squatters at 156 West End Lane in West Hampstead are evicted

Squatters have left empty former council offices in West Hampstead peacefully on Saturday morning after bailiffs arrived.

Yesterday, 15:11
Evidence for the trial

A woman from Crouch Hill has been disqualified from owning animals for life after keeping dogs in cages stacked on top of each other nearly every day.

Yesterday, 12:14
Neelu Berry

An activist making claims of satanic abuse at a Hampstead church could face three new charges of witness intimidation.

Yesterday, 14:03
Claudia Tabitha, 23, Big Issue vendor. Photo: Polly Hancock

A pregnant Big Issue vendor has been overwhelmed by generous offers of support from local parents.

Sunday, November 29, 2015
Hornsey Town Hall Appreciation Society members. From left Amanda Carrara, Chris Currer, Mark Afford, Miriam Levin and Dave Winskill.

The fight for community ownership of Hornsey Town Hall continues, even though the council officially invited bids from developers last week.

Sunday, November 29, 2015
Expedition 45 Commander SCOTT KELLY took this selfie photograph during a 7-hour and 16-minute spacewalk. This was the first spacewalk for both Kelly and Flight Engineer Kjell Lindgren; the two will venture outside the International Space Station for the second time on next Friday. Kelly becomes the U.S. astronaut who has lived in space the longest during a single U.S. spaceflight, and on Monday, Nov. 2, the crew celebrates the 15th year of a continuous human presence in space aboard the station. (Credit Image: © NASA/ZUMA Wire)

Young gardeners are preparing for a close encounter of the herbaceous kind when they attempt to grow seeds from outer space.

Sunday, November 29, 2015
Keir Starmer arrives with his wife Victoria at the election count. Picture: Polly Hancock

It’s been six months since Sir Keir Starmer won the safe Labour seat of Holborn and St Pancras by a huge majority.

Saturday, November 28, 2015
Volunteers plant a new herbaceous border to mark Waterlow Park's 125th anniversary. Picture: Polly Hancock

Volunteers armed with gardening forks and spades replanted a herbaceous border to mark a Highgate park’s 125th anniversary.

Most read news

Property Newsletter Sign-up

Get the latest North London property news and features straight to your inbox with our regular newsletter

I am also happy to receive other emails...
Fields marked with a * are mandatory
Email Marketing by e-shot


Nike Trainers

Nike’s motto is ‘to bring inspiration and innovation to every athlete in the world.’ With this in mind it’s no surprise why Nike is the preferred training gear for most A-list athletes. Get an extra boost in your run or height in your jump with £500 to spend on Nike trainers.

MAC Makeup

MAC are renowned for their flawless, fabulous make up that is used worldwide by the stars. You too can have the chance to have the perfect makeup to suit your needs with £1,000 to spend on all the glam goodies you like!

Digital Edition

Read the Hampstead & Highgate Express e-edition today E-edition
Family Notices 24

Local business directory

Our trusted business finder