Search

Highgate: Chartered accountant forged his mum’s signature to claim share of £160m business empire

16:46 16 February 2017

The High Court        Picture: Andrew Matthews/PA

The High Court Picture: Andrew Matthews/PA

PA Wire/PA Images

A chartered accountant and “self-confessed liar” from Highgate forged his dead mum’s will to guarantee himself a slice of his family’s £160million business empire.

Girish Dahyabhai Patel, 65, used an unrelated blank document pre-signed by his “astute and devout” mum – Prabhavati Dahyabhai Patel – to forge a will that gave him control of the family’s £40m palm oil plantation in Malaysia, his brother Yashwant claimed.

At the High Court today, Judge Andrew Simmonds QC found the will to be have been forged, adding: “The truth is a flexible concept for Girish, to be fashioned according to his own interests and requirements.”

Consequently, the entire fortune went to Yashwant, as specified in an older will, and settled a “bitterly fought litigation” between Girish and two of his three brothers.

Patel, who lives off Fitzroy Park in Highgate, was caught out by forensic analysis of the document that showed specks of printer ink on top of the signature, but none underneath, suggesting the signature came before the text.

He must now pay legal bills estimated at £1.3m, including £450,000 of his brother’s costs.

The court heard the family – from Gujarat in India – are successful businesspeople, with the palm plantation the “jewel in the crown” of an empire.

But Girish, who sits as an arbitrator in disputes, fell out with his three brothers in 2009, leaving him “at odds with some, or all” of them, said the judge.

A “long and acrimonious dispute” has since raged over control of the businesses, with legal cases ongoing in several different countries.

The brothers’ mum died aged 88 in September 2011, sparking fresh arguments in court.

First, Yashwant, who is a 69-year-old Newcastle-educated medical doctor, came forward with a will, made in 1986, leaving everything to him.

The document was approved, but Girish then launched a bid to overturn it, for the first time producing a document he claimed his mum had signed in 2005.

In the case, their brother Suresh, 63, backed Yashwant, while another, Rajnikant, 71, played no part.

Girish claimed that, on a visit to London from her home in Singapore in 2005, his mother had asked him to make a new will.

She was concerned that, on her death, some of her money might be given to the Swaminarayan Temple, in Edgware, a Hindu sect she did not support.

Instead, she insisted that the will be in Girish’s favour so that he could distribute to charities of her choosing when she died.

She had gone to his offices in Gorst Road, North Acton, and put her name to the will, translated into Gujarati by him in the presence of witnesses.

However, the judge said that, apart from “unreliable” evidence put forward by Girish, nothing backed up his account of how the will was signed.

“I find that there were available to Girish blank papers pre-signed by the deceased which enabled him to forge the will, utilising a genuine but old signature of the deceased,” said the judge.

Despite being told not to discuss their evidence, Girish and some of his witnesses had got together for a “last-minute joint revision” session before the trial to make sure their evidence was as consistent as possible.

He “exercised influence” over crucial witnesses in the trial, enabling him to “persuade them both falsely to witness the will”.

“Girish is a chartered accountant and sits as an arbitrator,” he continued. “I would, in the normal course of events, expect such a witness to be reliable and trustworthy.”

Latest Hampstead & Highgate News Stories

A woman from Gospel Oak born with a hole in her heart is to run 10km to raise money for the British Heart Foundation.

59 minutes ago

Euston station has been closed because of overcrowding and disruption caused by Storm Doris.

16:00

Children dressed as Voldemort and characters from 1984 are planning to descend on East Finchley Library to stage a World Book Day protest against Barnet Council’s “ridiculous” and “dangerously unsafe” libraries policy.

14:30

Council tax in Camden is set to rise by an extra 1 per cent – on top of the previously planned 3.99pc increase.

The owner has launched an investigation, as it would be ‘impossible’ for the famous stall to run up that amount of electricity in such a short amount of time

10:47

Highgate Wood and Golders Hill Park will be closed today because of strong winds.

10:01

In December, TfL snubbed popular opinion to change Archway’s bus system. Last week, this led to a sickening smash between a motorcyclist and bus. The Ham&High spoke to an enraged pub landlord who was first on the scene.

07:01

A much-loved nursery is fighting the threat of closure after more than a decade of dedicated service in Archway.

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to the following newsletters:

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Most read Hampstead & Highgate news

HOT JOBS

Show Job Lists

Competitions

Having a brand new kitchen is something that lots of people want but can only dream of. Sadly keeping up to date and making our living spaces as nice as they can be is a costly and incredibly stressful business. Even a fresh coat of paint makes all the difference but isn’t easy or quick.

Digital Edition

cover

Enjoy the
Hampstead & Highgate Express
e-edition today

Subscribe

Education and Training

cover

Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now