Chalcots residents disappointed after court rules that Camden Council is right to say they can return despite lingering fears over safety

PUBLISHED: 16:54 31 July 2017 | UPDATED: 17:09 31 July 2017

Chalcots residents group outside the Royal Courts of Justice after Monday's ruling

Chalcots residents group outside the Royal Courts of Justice after Monday's ruling


Chalcots residents who feel their homes are not safe were left disappointed today when a judge ruled that Camden Council did not have to keep paying for a resident’s temporary accommodation.

Court of Appeal judge Mrs Justice May turned down Leticia Esposito’s appeal for an injunction requiring the Council to extend her hotel accommodation until the results of tests on cladding are returned next week. The Council successfully argued that with fire safety works completed and signed off, residents were no longer entitled to temporary accommodation paid for by the council.

The case is likely to provide a precedent for any future suits brough by Chalcots residents against the Council, and any evacuees still in hotels will have to leave or start paying the costs themselves.

Residents were evacuated on June 23 after a London Fire Brigade inspection found immediate safety concerns; the Council has enacted a phased return, with all necessary works supposedly completed early last week. However, many residents feel that the work is insufficient and the blocks remain unsafe, a position corroborated by an independent building safety expert last week.

With the Council refusing to pay for temporary accommodation beyond the point at which they felt it safe for residents to return, some residents have resorted to legal action. Their suits are to demand the Council provide temporary accommodation until the completion of tests on the buildings’ cladding- which is of the same type that caused the Grenfell Tower inferno in June. Initial tests found the cladding contained no flame-retardant material- fuelling fears that the towers could go up in flames.

During Monday’s hearing, the Council’s legal team argued that the tests were not relevant to the evacuation, and that the schedule of works ordered by the LFB had been fulfilled and signed off by building inspectors. They also argued that requiring residents to return despite questions over the cladding was in line with central government guidance from the DCLG. But Ms Esposito’s solicitor Christopher Jacobs argued that it was ‘irrational’ for the council to instruct the claimant, who lives in Dorney tower, to return to an unsafe home, and breached her right to a safe home under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights.

But the judge found this case unconvincing, and agreed with the Council’s argument that the cladding was not relevant to the evacuation, to the disappointment of the sizeable group of Chalcots residents who had packed the courtroom’s public benches.

An emotional Ms Esposito was not available for comment after the ruling, but Taplow tower resident Ella May Chisholm-Hickey, 30, said she remained unwilling to return to her flat. “Camden presented a clever case, but I’m not going back,” she said. “I don’t feel it’s safe, and I’ve got small children. Just because we live in social housing, that doesn’t mean we should just accept any standards.”

Other residents said that further legal action would be taken; several mooted a crowd-funding campaign to hire an independent building inspector and pay legal fees.

Latest Hampstead & Highgate News Stories


A 23-year-old woman has been sentenced after attacking a railway worker with some of the “worst racial abuse” he had ever heard.

Yesterday, 18:44

A sixth teenager has been charged by police over the fatal stabbing of 19-year-old Lewis Blackman, otherwise known as ‘Dotz’.

Yesterday, 14:09

The leader of Camden Conservatives and councillor for Frognal and Fitzjohns has rubbished claims by Owen Jones that he doesn’t hold surgeries, and all Tory candidates in the ward are Brexit supporters.

Yesterday, 10:50

New figures have highlighted the intense pressure the Whittington Hospital estate was under during winter.

Mon, 19:53

Homeland actress Nazanin Boniadi joined Richard Ratcliffe, the husband of jailed West Hampstead mum Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe, at a special performance of a play to raise awareness of his wife’s plight.

A group of 15 budding politicians have launched their campaigns to become Camden’s next youth MP.

Mon, 17:00

Only mad dogs and Englishmen go out in the midday sun. Or so the saying goes. However it was only Camden’s political activists and left-wing campaigner Owen Jones who braved the snow on a freezing Saturday morning.

Mon, 15:25

Hoaxers made bomb threats to schools in Camden, Haringey and Barnet this morning in a plot targeting primaries and secondaries around the country.


Melange, with locations in Barnet and Crouch End, has opened a third in Belsize Park. Here co-owner Justina Markauskaite talks about removing the borders between cuisines and why they put family at the centre of everything they do

Toni Krok, who was diagnosed with multiple sclerosis in 2007, has set up a charity to help people living with the condition and their families adjust to the challenges it brings.

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to the following newsletters:

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Most read Hampstead & Highgate news

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition


Enjoy the
Hampstead & Highgate Express
e-edition today


Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now