Search

Camden faces £10million bill for illegal parking tickets

13:34 25 February 2011

A HIGH court judge has upheld a ruling that tens of thousands of parking fines issued by Camden Council in the first half of 2009 are illegal.

The judgment relates to a policy the council launched in January 2009 of charging an administration fee when drivers paid parking tickets by credit cards.

The charges were scrapped six months after they were introduced when an independent parking adjudicator deemed this practice unlawful.

But this decision effectively invalidated the tickets issued when the surcharge was in place and led to calls for the council to pay back the fines, which were reported to total £25million.

However, Camden now claims this figure is closer to £10million.

The latest judgment has now renewed the prospect that the council will have to repay millions of pounds

And ParkingAppeals.com, the organisation who brought the initial case against the surcharge, have warned that they will bring further legal action if Camden fail to do so.

Neil Herron, director of the lobby group, said: “I think there’s no doubt it – Camden has had the money unlawfully. It has been illegally enriched. Therefore the full amount of the money has to be refunded.

“It’s a legal issue because the tickets weren’t legal. So they have a moral, legal and financial obligation to refund the money.”

Richard Chaumeton, of London Motoring Action Group, agreed that in moral terms the council should be made to pay back the penalties, but accepted this may not be viable in the current economic climate.

He said: “It’s a marvellous outcome. Camden have prostituted parking for too long.

“They’ve been caught out yet again. They think they’re above the law and they’re not.

“I think having the hassle of paying back the 50p charge is not practical, but morally they should give the money back.”

The challenges to the 1.3 per cent fee on the credit card payments date back to June 1, 2009, when an adjudicator for the Parking and Traffic Appeals Service (PATAS) ruled that the surcharges were unlawful.

The council attempted to appeal against this judgement in three further hearings, but on each occasion PATAS upheld its original decision.

Then in November last year, after being granted a judicial review, Camden took their case to the High Court.

But this week Town Hall bsses were disappointed once again when Mr Justice Burnett dismissed their challenge.

He concluded that the credit card charge had the effect of increasing the parking fine and amounted to a “procedural impropriety”

Camden Council has not confirmed whether they will make the repayments, but say they are considering their next move.

A council spokesman said: “We are disappointed by the ruling and will be reflecting on the judgement and the implications for the council in the coming days.”

0 comments

Latest News Stories

Yesterday, 12:39
Bob Warnock outside the Royal Courts of Justice after the verdict was handed down

The superintendent of Hampstead Heath said he was pleased the outcome of the dams project judicial review has provided “clarity” – and he insisted it will “enhance” the landscape.

Yesterday, 12:11
Members of the Heath swimming associations outside the Royal Courts of Justice. Picture: Polly Hancock

Opponents of the Hampstead Heath dams project insist the fight is not over after losing their High Court challenge – and they are set to lobby the environment secretary and Camden Council.

Yesterday, 12:55
The YouGov webpage about the Ham&High

You are Mercedes-Benz drivers who are arrogant, introverted, curious and daydreamers!

Yesterday, 12:00
Lorraine Chase and Peter Egan with Ira Moss (left) from charity All Dogs Matter at Burgh House 23.11.14. with the cake donated by supporter Ricky Gervais.

It was a busy day for dog rescue charity All Dogs Matter on Sunday.

Most read news

The comedian returned to his home town for the prestigious award ceremony.

The helicopter crashed through the roof of the Clutha pub.

Twitter sat back and watched as the world went bargain-hunting crazy on Black Friday.

There was definitely something buzzing at JCB when he delivered his immigration speech.

Digital Edition

Image
Read the Hampstead & Highgate Express e-edition today E-edition