The Forbidden Room, review: ‘A hateful experience’

17:00 16 December 2015

The Forbidden Room. Picture: Kino Lorber, Inc.

The Forbidden Room. Picture: Kino Lorber, Inc.

Credit: Courtesy Kino Lorber, Inc.

Guy Maddin’s rambling, dream-like phantasmagoria is guelling and precious, but there is some satisfaction to be had here, writes Michael Joyce.

Guy Maddin, the avant garde Canadian film maker with a fetish for recreating the look and style of silent cinema and the early talkies, is closer to video artist than mainstream movie maker and The Forbidden Room is like something you might see projected onto the wall of the Tate Modern. Except this has stars, some exceptional visual effects, and you can’t wander off non nonplussed after a couple of minutes.

Maddin wants two hours of your time to show you what may be his magnum opus, a rambling, phantasmagoria of stops and starts, bits and bobs. In a submarine carrying an unstable cargo of gelignite the already jittery crew suddenly discover a lumberjack aboard; next we see said lumberjack in the forest trying to rescue the beautiful Margot from the wolfpack that has captured her; and on and on it goes, stories within stories, dreams within dreams flowing into each other and then doubling back to catch up with the vignettes later on. This is a film that comes close to replicating the logic of a dream but only if this Finnegan is a film archivist whose subconscious is filled with title cards, back projection, black and white, and rocket ships held up by string.

The concentrated visual intensity of it (almost all of the film is shot in close up) and the garish colour scheme makes it a hard, almost gruelling film to get through. I found it precious, garish and twee, a hateful experience, yet as the lights came up there was a certain satisfaction at having made it to the end.

Rating: 2/5 stars

Latest Hampstead & Highgate Stories


Of all the bulbs, tulips are probably the most varied in size and colour, ranging from dainty dwarf specimens to frilly, feathery forms and stand-up-straight majestic types.


Spurs played out their second goalless draw in the space of five days after a 0-0 tie against Bournemouth on the south coast. Here are five talking points.

A colourful man-about-town has reformed his fringe political party on the back of the Brexit result - which he said is “a step in the right direction” towards abolishing the existing system

Yesterday, 18:23

There’s a raft of developments hitting the market at the moment, which are perfectly designed to appeal to downsizers who are more hip than hip replacement (although many of these new builds, with their emphasis on lateral living, will cater for this eventuality too).

Yesterday, 16:26

Controversial plans to build a 10-storey “big ugly block” of luxury flats in Hampstead were last night waved through by Camden Council.

Yesterday, 16:00

Spencer McCall is immediately targeting a new objective – avenging Hendon’s opening day defeat to Worthing – after their FA Cup dreams evaporated at Boreham Wood.

Yesterday, 15:00

Ken Loach’s new Cannes favourite tells the story of a man trapped in a system that refuses to serve him

Yesterday, 14:11

Living space comes at a premium, and if you’ve been hoarding all summer then autumn’s the perfect time to declutter and make space for the things that will not only complement your lifestyle, but create a sense of order.

Most read Hampstead & Highgate etcetera


Show Job Lists

Digital Edition


Enjoy the
Hampstead & Highgate Express
e-edition today


Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now