Carol review: ‘An Oscar Pleader that has become a real film’

10:00 29 November 2015

Cate Blanchett in Carol. Picture: Wilson Webb/Studio Canal

Cate Blanchett in Carol. Picture: Wilson Webb/Studio Canal


This adaptation of Patricia Highsmith’s autobiographical novel has all the signs of Academy-baiting, but Carol’s small moments, acting and score make for a perfect fit, says Michael Joyce.

Film composer Carter Burwell is, in a field known for its bombast, a master of understatement. His best scores are softly insistent, summoning up a gentle foreboding while at the same time being quietly enticing; they work overtime drawing audiences into the film maker’s vision. He is best known for his work with the Coen Brothers but has found a perfect fit in this ‘50s romance between two women. The discrete way he underscores emotions is ideal for a tale of a love that dare not speak its name, set in a time when a lid was kept on that kind of thing.

In the winter of 1952, the well-to-do Carol (Blanchett) is looking for a Christmas present for her daughter in Manhattan when she catches the eye of shop assistant Therese (Mara). A romance cautiously develops, but it is complicated by her husband’s reluctance to let their marriage end and a custody battle for their child ensue.

Carol is like an Oscar Pleader that has become a real film. It has all the Academy-baiting elements – period setting, liberal agenda, based on a novel and a true story, an autobiographical novel written under a pseudonym by Patricia Highsmith.

And it has Cate Blanchett in it. A Blanchett performance is never a casual or relaxed thing. Carol looks immaculate in every scene, while Blanchett is meticulously controlled in everything she does. And she needs to be: this is a film of small moments and tiny gestures, everything has to be carefully measured. Playing against her, Rooney Mara is almost entirely reactive. She doesn’t need to show you all the effort she is making, she just instinctively gets it right.

Rating: 4/5 stars

Latest Hampstead & Highgate Stories

Yesterday, 12:00
The Knowledge of Good and Evil by Jonathan McCree

Closer to the Veg sees 16 artists collaborating with 30 plot holders to explore themes of sustainability and destruction, labour and leisure, loneliness and communality.

Yesterday, 10:07
Get someone in to water your plants while you're on holiday. PA Photo/thinkstockphotos

If you’re away for a fortnight in the summer holidays and don’t want to return to bedraggled borders, dried-out pots and a lawn which looks like straw, take action now.

Yesterday, 09:00
Tracey Palmer, Macmillan information and support manager at The Whittington Hospital, and Angel Bellot, the hospital's PALS and complaints manager (Picture: Eve Harris)

Two brave Whittington workers will swap the wards for the sky (and then, hopefully, the ground) when they jump out of a plane for charity this weekend.

Yesterday, 08:04
Members of Power up North London, Ian Grant,Nikki Brain,Vijay Bhopal & Ben Pearce,pictured at St Anne's Church Highgate where they have been given permission to install Solar Panels on the roof. Photo: Nigel Sutton

A Grade II-listed church in Highgate will open up to rays of light above, after a community group won planning permission for solar panels to be installed on the slope of its roof

Fri, 19:04
The 8 Series Colour Sliding Door in Gold, from £1,495.20, available from Merlyn Showering, visit for nearest stockist

Stepping under a cascading shower can be one of the most luxurious feelings in the world. But turning the shower on to be greeted with a pathetic little trickle can be one of the most frustrating and disappointing experiences!

Fri, 15:16
Spencer McCall (right)

Hendon signing Spencer McCall believes the club should be challenging for the Ryman League Premier Division play-offs as an absolute minimum this season.

Fri, 15:02
A family enjoys fun in the sun. Picture: John Macdonald-Fulton

School’s out for summer – great for children, but for parents, it can be a challenge to find enough activities to keep youngsters entertained over the six-week break.

Fri, 13:43
Neelu Berry arrives at Highbury Corner Magistrates Court 07.10.15.

Two campaigners accused of spreading discredited claims of a Satanic paedophile ring have been told they must stay away from a vicar and his parishioners.

Most read Hampstead & Highgate etcetera


Show Job Lists

Digital Edition


Enjoy the
Hampstead & Highgate Express
e-edition today


Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now