Logo

Ofsted under fire after failing ultra-Orthodox Jewish school for being too religious

PUBLISHED: 07:30 09 April 2015

Talmud Torah Tiferes Shlomoh Jewish school in Golders Green. Picture: Nigel Sutton

Talmud Torah Tiferes Shlomoh Jewish school in Golders Green. Picture: Nigel Sutton

© Nigel Sutton email pictures@nigelsuttonphotography.com

A damning Ofsted report into an ultra-Orthodox Jewish school has raised serious concerns that the government watchdog does not treat faith schools fairly.

Ofsted chief inspector Sir Michael Wilshaw. Picture: John StillwellOfsted chief inspector Sir Michael Wilshaw. Picture: John Stillwell

Talmud Torah Tiferes Shlomoh, in Golders Green, has been branded a failing school by Ofsted, which judged it spends too much time teaching Jewish religious studies.

Pupils at the all-boys independent school are therefore “inadequately prepared for life in modern Britain”, inspectors ruled under guidelines brought in following the Trojan Horse Islamic extremism scandal in Birmingham schools last year.

But the verdict has prompted the National Association for Orthodox Jewish Schools to hit out at Ofsted, saying it is unduly harsh to strictly religious Jewish schools.

Executive director Jonathan Rabson said: “We have been very concerned recently about the high-handed approach of Ofsted in relation to their inspection of strictly orthodox schools, especially those in the independent sector.

“We have gone on record as saying that inspectors have often used insensitive and inappropriate questions with faith schools and have failed to understand the religious context that underpins the ethos of the schools, judging them by secular standards.”

But in a statement, Ofsted chief inspector Sir Michael Wilshaw said: “As a former headteacher of a Catholic secondary school, the charge that I am presiding over some sort of state-sponsored, anti-faith school ‘witch-hunt’ would be laughable – were it not so serious.

“I have long been a staunch supporter and proponent of faith schools in this country, believing that they are a valuable and enduring feature of our education landscape.

“Let me offer this unequivocal reassurance – the vast majority of faith schools have nothing to fear either from Ofsted or from the recent guidance issued by the department for education on promoting British values as part of the curriculum.”

Most of the Talmud Torah Tiferes Shlomoh’s 219 pupils go on to secure places at Jewish religious colleges, known as yeshivas, which focus on the study of the Talmud and Torah.

The school for boys aged three to 15, in Elmcroft Crescent, is rated highly by parents and the Jewish community and places are often over-subscribed.

In 2010 and 2007, the school was judged by Ofsted to provide a “good” standard of education.

But by last month, following a snap inspection in January, this was downgraded to the lowest possible rating of “inadequate”.

Ofsted said the school does not teach pupils basic skills such as spelling, grammar and punctuation. Pupils mostly learn to read in Hebrew and lack fluency in reading English as a result, the inspector said.

Pupils only learn a restricted set of secular subjects and are “shielded” from learning about sex, drugs or sexual orientation, the inspector wrote.

Conservative Finchley and Golders Green parliamentary candidate Mike Freer said he was very surprised at Ofsted’s remarks.

“I’m very happy to raise any concerns the school has with Ofsted itself,” he pledged. “Faith schools do an extremely good job but they do have to prepare pupils for the wider world.”

But Trudy Gold, a former director of education at the London Jewish Cultural Centre in Golders Green, said the report is part of a worrying new trend in faith schools.

“I don’t think Ofsted is picking on Orthodox Jewish schools,” she said. “I think it’s more of a fear that we are breeding extremism in our society and I find it quite dangerous, whether it be Jewish, Muslim or evangelical Christian.”

She added: “I think it’s difficult for faith schools to find the balance, but it’s vital for an integrated society.”

Rabbi Stuart Altshuler, of Belsize Square Synagogue in Belsize Park, added his concerns.

“Jewish schools should follow the same rules as everybody else,” he said. “Jewish schools, Muslim schools, Christian schools all have the same obligation to be part of our greater society.”

The school declined to comment.

Latest Hampstead & Highgate education news

A-level results 2017: Camden schools above national average

Camden schools have performed above the national average in this year’s A-level results.

Westminster Academy student in top two per cent of country afters stellar IBDP results

An Oxford-bound Westminster Academy student has placed herself in the top two per cent of the country globally after achieving a stellar score in the International Baccalaureate Diploma Programme (IBDP).

A-level results 2017: Henrietta Barnett School students will go on to ‘achieve great things’

Henrietta Barnnett School’s students are set to achieve great things, according to headteacher Del Cooke.

A-level results 2017: Talent for maths clear for all to see at UCL Academy

The talent for maths at the UCL Academy is clear for all to see after almost half of A-level students achieved an A* or an A grade in the subject.

A-level results 2017: Greig City Academy students ‘exceed expectations’

The majority of students have exceeded their expectations at Greig City Academy, according to the head of sixth form.

A-level results 2017: Dedication of Regent High School students and quality of teaching lauded

The dedication of students and quality of teaching has been lauded by the head of Regent High School after an “impressive” A-level results day.

A-levels results day 2017: ‘Pioneering’ South Hampstead High School students secure ‘outstanding’ results across board

It’s been another outstanding year for South Hampstead High School after 73pc cent of students managed to secure A* or A grades – a figure which is about three times above the national average.

A-level results day 2017: Record results for Swiss Cottage school Quintin Kynaston

Record results were achieved for the fourth year in a row by Quintin Kynaston’s sixth-formers.

A-level results 2017: Westminster Kingsway College students are record breakers

Students at Westminster Kingsway College are celebrating a record-breaking year after collecting their A-level results this morning.

A-Level Results Day 2017: Hornsey Sixth Form College celebrates 130 years with 96 per cent pass rate

Hornsey Sixth Form College has even more reason to celebrate its 130th year as the A level class of 2017 notch up a 96 per cent pass rate.

A Level Results Day 2017: Outgoing Fortismere School headteacher proud of ‘outstanding’ performance

Fortismere School’s outgoing headteacher has hailed “another record breaking” year of A-Level results.

A-Level results day 2017: Laid-back King Alfred School in Golders Green sees success across the board

An informal atmosphere and an emphasis on trips and extra-curricular activities were the key to success at a Golders Green school progressive independent school, according to staff.

A-level results day 2017: Oxbridge candidates successful as Channing School students go from strength to strength

Students at Channing School have gone from strength to strength after receiving another stellar set of A-level results.

A-Level Results Day 2017: Highgate School headteacher proud after students break top grades record

Highgate School students are thrilled and relieved after scooping a record-breaking set of A-level results.

A-level results day 2017: UCS Hampstead headteacher hails success of ‘first guinea pigs of major educational reform’

The headteacher of UCS Hampstead has lauded the success of a batch of A-level students described as “the first guinea pigs of major educational reform”.

A-level results day 2017: Portland Place School students celebrate 96% pass rate

Staff and students are celebrating this morning after this year’s crop bagged an overall pass rate of 96per cent in their A-level results.

A-Level results day 2017: Everything you need to know

Thursday marks A-Levels results day, when students at sixth forms and colleges across Camden, Haringey, Barnet and Westminster will finally know more about what comes next.

Barnstorming night at The Roundhouse sees Highgate School, Fortismere School and Acland Burghley School come together

It was a barnstorming return to The Roundhouse for Highgate School’s third annual showcase.

GCSE results day 2017: What you need to know about the new grading system

In three weeks time we will see the first cohort of GCSE students decipher a mix of letters and numbers in their results. Here’s our guide to the new numerical grading system and what it means for pupils.

St Michael’s Primary School student, 6, has first haircut in aid of cancer charity

A six-year-old girl’s first ever haircut was an extra special one after she donated her chopped off locks to a cancer charity.

Year 6 students dazzle during performance on new Highgate Primary School stage

The opening of Highgate Primary School’s new outside stage has been christened with a show-stopping performance of Joseph by Year 6 students.

Haverstock School stalwarts bow out after decades of loyal service

A pair of Haverstock School stalwarts are retiring after decades of loyal service.

Gospel Oak Primary School student pens winning story in Really Big Pants Theatre competition

The Really Big Pants Theatre called on kids to take inspiration from their production of ‘Suddenly’ by writing a story - here is an extract from the winner, eight-year-old Tilly from Gospel Oak Primary School.

East Finchley schoolchildren take to Whitehall to protest against culture secretary’s cuts to Barnet library services

East Finchley schoolchildren descended on Whitehall to protest against their loss of access to libraries in Barnet borough.

Mother-of-four on a mission to transform handwriting skills of London schoolchildren

A mother-of-four is on a mission to transform the handwriting skills of schoolchildren.

Author of The Demon Headmaster pays visit to St Joseph’s Catholic Primary School

It was a devilish end-of-term library session for youngsters at St Joseph’s Catholic Primary School with the visit of an award-winning author.

Chasm emerges among Jewish community as Orthodox rabbis call for boycott of JW3 cultural centre in Hampstead

Orthodox rabbis in St John’s Wood and Golders Green have called on their congregations to boycott Hampstead Jewish cultural centre JW3 in protest at the cultural centre’s promotion of ‘lifestyles and behaviours forbidden by the Torah’.

Student, 17, debates Hornsey and Wood Green MP Catherine West on Brexit

A devoted remain MP was quizzed this week by a young Brexiteer during a politics summer school.

Q and A: South Hampstead High School headteacher Vicky Bingham

We spoke to Vicky Bingham about why she loves being headteacher of South Hampstead High School.

Campaign group formed to defend schools from education cuts hails impact of Camden and Haringey parents and teachers

A campaign group formed to defend schools from education cuts has hailed the impact of parents and teachers in forcing the government to better protect funding for students across Camden and Haringey.

Haringey families set to descend on Parliament Square for mass ‘protest picnic’ against school funding cuts

Parents are set to descend on Parliament Square on Sunday for a mass ‘picnic protest’ against school funding cuts.

Channing School headteacher conquers fears and raises £45,000 with skydive from 12,000 feet

The sky is the limit for the headteacher of an independent girls’ school who faced her ultimate fear.

Highgate School student has leadership skills tested as he takes on being headteacher for day

A Year 8 had his leadership skills tested after winning a competition to be Highgate School’s headteacher for the day.

Roll up, roll up: Highgate School summer fair kicks into gear

The Highgate School summer fair is kicking into gear on Saturday and the organisers reckon it is going to be the best one yet.

American School in London hoping to provide youngsters with summer of lifetime once again

Providing youngsters with the summer of a lifetime is the motivation for a St John’s Wood school which has been putting on camps for more than a quarter of a century.

Swiss Cottage School is one of country’s best after sixth consecutive ‘outstanding’ Ofsted

Swiss Cottage School has become one of a handful of schools to be given an “outstanding” Ofsted rating for the sixth time in a row.

Former refugees reunite at Chalk Farm school where they met

Two women who arrived in the UK as refugees have returned to the school where they became friends.

Students ditch smartphones and go back to basics in pioneering King Alfred School project

For one week in the summer term, 50 King Alfred School students camp outdoors with six teachers and form their own community.

Highgate Wood School, Fortismere School, Greig City Academy and Hornsey School for Girls star in Haringey awards ceremony

The future is bright in Haringey after a stellar array of school role models were celebrated.

What art education decline? Highgate School students pull off stellar exhibition

Despite widespread fears that art education is in decline, students at Highgate School have shown that there is plenty of appetite for the subject after a stellar exhibition.

From basketball star to debating champion: Haringey high achievers set for Jack Petchey awards

A basketball superstar, champion of debating and teenage interpreter are just some of the characters being rewarded for achieving great things in Haringey this year.

Concerns grow over Muswell Hill Library’s future

Suspicions a much-loved public library could be moved have led to anxiety for its supporters.

Q and A: The Cavendish School headteacher Jane Rogers

In our latest question and answer feature for Ham&High Education, we interviewed The Cavendish School headteacher Jane Rogers.

Teenager dies after being found unresponsive at Hampstead Garden Suburb school

A teenage girl has died after being found unresponsive at her school.

Hampstead child psychiatrist pens parental guide to help build kids’ self-esteem

A child psychiatrist believes that having conversations with your children from a young age is vital in building their self-esteem.

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to the following newsletters:

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

2017 © Archant Community Media Ltd

Terms and conditions | Cookie policy | Jobs at Archant